The Bolshevik Party Transformed: Stalin’s Rise to Power (1917–1927)

James Harris

Abstract


In 1917, the Bolsheviks promised the liberation of the working masses from exploitation. And yet, within twenty years, they had delivered a regime that was substantially more exploitative and repressive than that of the Tsarist regime they had overthrown. This article argues that more than a quarter of a century after the opening of the archives, we still misapprehend how it happened. Historians tend to see the process as programmatic, or planned and intentional: that the Bolsheviks were authoritarian by nature, or that Stalin hijacked the Revolution and satisfied his lust for power by building a personal dictatorship. The article
argues that we have failed to grasp the extent to which the positive programme of liberation continued to motivate the Bolshevik leadership throughout the interwar period. But they had underestimated the obstacles to creating a consensual, participatory political order. Considerable progress was made overcoming basic illiteracy, but it was another matter altogether to establish a functioning administrative apparatus, to fight and win the civil war, and to rebuild a shattered
economy. The breakdown of liberal (“bourgeois”) democracies in Europe encouraged complacency about the superiority of the “transitional” proletarian dictatorship. The struggle for power after Lenin’s death turned local organisations against inner party democracy. It did not seem appropriate to revive it either in the midst of collectivisation and rapid industrialisation. The survival of the Revolution and catching up to the advanced capitalist countries took precedence. But if we treat extreme political violence and dictatorship as ends in themselves, we will fail adequately to grasp the fate of the Revolution.


Keywords


Stalin; democracy; dictatorship; bolshevism

References


Carr, E. H. (1979). The Russian Revolution from Lenin to Stalin. L., Macmillan. 200 p.

Cohen, S. F. (1973). Bukharin and the Bolshevik Revolution: a Political Biography, 1888–1938. N. Y., A. A. Knopf. 519 p.

Collins, D. (1976). The Russian Red Guard of 1917 and Lenin’s Utopia. In J. of Russian Studies. No. 1, pp. 3–12.

Conquest, R. (1968). The Great Terror: Stalin’s Purge of the Thirties. L., Macmillan. 633 p. Cook, L. (2013). Collegiality in the People’s Commissariats, 1917–1920. In Revolutionary Russia. No. 1, pp. 1–31.

Daniels, R. V. (1960). The Conscience of the Revolution: Communist Opposition in Soviet Russia. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard Univ. Press. 524 p.

Davies, S., Harris, J. (2014). Stalin’s World: Dictating the Soviet Order. N. Haven, Yale Univ. Press. 340 p.

DAVO [State Archive of the Vinnytsia Region]. Stock 1. List 1. Dos. 5; Stock 1. List 1. Dos. 43; Dos. 44; Dos. 45.

Deutscher, I. (1949). Stalin: A Political Biography. L., Oxford Univ. Press. 600 p. Englander, D. (1987). Military Intelligence and the Defense of the Realm: the Surveillance of Soldiers and Civilians in Britain during the First World War. In Bulletin of the Society for the Study of Labour History. No. 1, pp. 24–32.

Fitzpatrick, S. (1989). The Civil War as a Formative Experience. In Gleason, A., Kenez P., Stites R. (Eds.). Bolshevik Culture: Experiment and Order in the Russian Revolution. Bloomington, Ind., Indiana Univ. Press. 305 p.

Fox, J., Welch, D. (Eds.) (2012). Justifying War: Propaganda, Politics and the Modern Age. Basingstoke, Macmillan. 414 p.

Friedrich, C., Brzezinski, Z. (1956). Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy. Cambridge, Mass., Harvard Univ. Press. 346 p.

Getty, J. A. (2013). Practicing Stalinism: Bolsheviks, Boyars and the Persistence of Tradition. N. Haven, Yale Univ. Press. 359 p.

Gill, G. (1990). The Origins of the Stalinist Political System. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 454 p.

Harris, J. (2005). Stalin as General Secretary: The Appointments Process and the Nature of Stalin’s Power. In Davies S., Harris J. (Eds.). Stalin: A New History. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 295 p.

Harris, J. (2007). Encircled by Enemies: Stalin’s Perceptions of the Capitalist World, 1918–1941. In J. of Strategic Studies. No. 3, pp. 513–545.

Holquist, P. (1997). Information is the Alpha and Omega of Our Work: Bolshevik Surveillance in its Pan European Context. In J. of Modern History. No. 3, pp. 415–450.

Khlevniuk, O. (2009). Master of the House: Stalin and His Inner Circle. N. Haven, Yale Univ. Press. 313 p.

Kotkin, S. (2014). Stalin: Volume I. Paradoxes of Power, 1878–1928. N. Y., Penguin. 976 p.

Kowalski, R. (1991). The Bolshevik Party in Conflict: The Left Communist Opposition of 1918. Basingstoke, Macmillan. 244 p.

KPSS v rezoliutsiiakh i resheniiakh s’’ezdov, konferentsii i plenumov TsK (1898–1986) (1986) [The CPSU in resolutions and decisions of congresses, conferences and plenums of the Central Committee (1898–1986)]. T. 3 (1922–1925). Moscow, Politizdat. 494 p.

Laue, T. H. Von. (1964). Why Lenin? Why Stalin? A Reappraisal of the Russian Revolution, 1900–1930. Philadelphia, Lippincott. 242 p.

LeBon, G. (1896). The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind. L., T. Fisher Unwin. 230 p.

Lenin, V. I. (1966). Uderzhat li bolsheviki gosudarstvennuiu vlast’? [Can the Bolsheviks tate Power?]. In Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Izd. 4. T. 34. Moscow, Politizdat, pp. 306–307.

Lewin, M. (1978). State, Society and Ideology during the First Five-Year Plan. In Fitzpatrick S. (Ed.). Cultural Revolution in Russia, 1928–1931. Bloomington, Ind., Indiana Univ. Press. 309 p.

Malia, M. (1994). The Soviet Tragedy: A History of Socialism in Russia, 1917–1991. N. Y., Free Press. 575 p.

McAuley, M. (1991). Bread and Justice: State and Society in Petrograd, 1917–1922. Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press. 461 p.

Pethybridge, R. (1974). The Social Prelude to Stalinism. L., Macmillan. 343 p.

Pietsch, W. (1969). Revolution und Staat. Institutionen als Trager der Macht in Sowjetrussland 1917–1922. Cologne, Verlag Wissenschaft und Politik. 214 p.

Pipes, R. (1993). Russia under the Bolshevik Regime. N. Y., A. A. Knopf. 587 p.

Priestland, D. (2007). Stalinism and the Politics of Mobilization: Ideas, Power and Terror in Inter-war Russia. Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press. 487 p.

Rabinowitch, A. (1976). The Bolsheviks Come to Power: the Revolution of 1917 in Petrograd. N. Y., W. W. Norton. 393 p.

Remington, T. (1984). Building Socialism in Bolshevik Russia: Ideology and Industrial Organisation, 1917–1921. Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh Univ. Press. 221 p.

Rigby, T. H. (1979). Lenin’s Government: Sovnarkom 1917–1922. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 320 p.

RGASPI [Russian State Archive of Socio-economic History]. Stock 17. List 69. Dos. 140; Stock 17. List 3. Dos. 337; Dos. 339; Stock 17. List 84. Dos. 470; Stock 17. List 171. Dos. 26; Stock 17. List 84. Dos. 476; Stock 17. List 3. Dos. 400; Stock 558. List 1. Dos. 2569; Stock 17. List 84. Dos. 476; Stock 17. List 171. Dos. 26.

Schapiro, L. (1955). The Origin of the Communist Autocracy: Political Opposition in the Soviet State, First Phase, 1917–1922. L., G. Bell and Sons. 397 p.

Schapiro, L. (1984). 1917: The Russian Revolutions and the Origins of Present-day Communism. Hounslow, Maurice Temple Smith. 239 p.

Service, R. (1979). The Bolshevik Party in Revolution: A Study in Organisational Change, 1917–1923. Basingstoke, Macmillan. 246 p.

Smith, J. (1998). The Georgian Affair of 1922. Policy Failure, Personality Clash or Power Struggle? In Europe-Asia Studies. No. 3, pp. 519–544.

Smith, S. A. (1983). Red Petrograd: Revolution in the Factories, 1917–18. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 347 p.

Spengler, O. (1918). Der Untergang des Abendlandes. Wien, Braumüller. 414 p.

Stalin, I. V. (1952). Sochineniya. T. VII. Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoyj literaturih. 424 p.

Sternhell, Z. (1996). The Intellectual Revolt Against Liberal Democracy, 1870–1945. Jerusalem, Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities. 397 p.

Suny, R. G. (1994). The Making of the Georgian Nation. Bloomington, Ind., Indiana Univ. Press. 448 p.

Trotsky, L. (1940). Stalin: an Appraisal of the Man and His Influence. L., Harper. 516 p.

Trotsky, L. (1943). The Struggle for the New Course. N. Y., N. Intern. Publ. Co. 265 p.

TsDOOSO [Center for Documentation of Social Organizations of Sverdlovsk Region]. Stock 4. List 2. Dos. 45; Stock 8. List 1. Dos. 42; Stock 1494. List 1. Dos. 190.

Tucker, R. C. (1973). Stalin as Revolutionary, 1879–1929: a Study in History and Personality. N. Y., W. W. Norton. 568 p.

Tucker, R. C. (1990). Stalin in Power: the Revolution from Above, 1928–1941. N. Y., W. W. Norton. 707 p.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/qr.2017.3.245

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 2311-911X (Print)
ISSN 2310-757X (Online)

 

BASE Search eLibrary WorldCat