On ‘Age-old Russian Backwardness’

Alexander Kamensky

Abstract


This article considers the applicability of the concept of backwardness which was one of the basic concepts of both Russian and Western historiography of prerevolutionary Russia until the late 20th century and resulted from the constant comparison of Russia with the conventional ‘West’. On the one hand, modern historiography is characterised by a ‘normalisation’ of Russian history, i.e. attempts to prove that, considered generally, Russian historical development was identical to that of Western Europe, and, on the other hand, complete refusal to compare Russia and the West due to Russia having an altogether different and unique model of historical development. However, both of these trends contradict the worldview Russians had between the 18th and early 20th centuries. The author characterises both trends as dead ends as the concept of Russia’s ‘normality’ makes it impossible to explain the events of the imperial era, while the other approach deprives a historian of one of the major research tools in studying the past. It results in an intellectual trap, and the author suggests that to solve this problem, scholars should create a new language of historical research and accumulate empirical data that would create a more complex and multidimensional image of the past.


Keywords


historiography; Russian history; concept of backwardness; modernisation; comparative studies

References


Buldakov, V. P. (2017). Bich satiry i revolyutsiya. Vmesto predisloviya [The Scourge of Satire and the Revolution. Instead of a Preface]. In Bich 1917. Sobytiya goda v satire sovremennikov. Moscow, Boslen, pp. 11–12.

Catherine II (2010). Nakaz komissii o sochinenii proekta novogo ulozheniya [The Great Instruction to the Legislative Commission]. In Ekaterina II. Izbrannoye. Moscow, ROSSPEN, pp. 115‒189.

Davydov, M. A. (2010). Vserossiiskyi rynok v kontse XIX – nachale XX vv. i zheleznodorozhnaya statistika [The All-Russia Market in the Late 19th – Early 20th Centuries and Railway Statistics]. St Petersburg, Aleteiya. 832 p.

Dogoniayushee razvitie [The Catching-up Development]. (2003). In Lopatnikov, L. I. Ekonomiko-matematicheskii slovar’. Slovar’ sovremennoi ekonomicheskoi nauki. Moscow, Delo. URL: http://economic_mathematics.academic.ru/1475 (mode of access 14.10.2017).

Efimov, A. (2017). S chego my vzyali. Tri veka popytok ponyat’ Rossiyu umom [Why We Think so. Three Centuries of Attempts to Understand Russia with Mind alone]. Moscow, Individuum. 413 p.

Florya, B. N. (1992). “Sluzhebnaya organizatsiya” i ee rol’ v razvitii feodal’nogo obshchestva u vostochnykh i zapadnykh slavyan [Service Organisation and its Role in the Development of Feudal Society of the Eastern and Western Slavs]. In Otechestvennaya istoriya. No. 2, pp. 56‒74.

Gerschenkron, A. (1962). Economic Backwardness in Historical Perspective: A Book of Essays. Cambridge, Massachusetts, Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press. 456 p.

Gibson, L. (2008). All Quite on the Forefront. In University of Chicago Magazine. Jan. / Febr. Vol. 100. Iss. 3. URL: http://magazine.uchicago.edu/0812/investigations/all_quiet.shtml (mode of access: 14.10.2017).

H-Net: Humanities et Social Sciences Online [web-portal]. URL: http://h-net.msu.edu/cgi-bin/logbrowse.pl?trx=vx&list=h-russia&month=0610&week=b&msg=1cNaeDLXdnPo1yeHLtTAJA&user=&pw= (mode of access: 07.10.2017).

Kamenskii, A. (2004). Russian and Western Eighteenth-Century Towns: Possible Aspects of Comparison. In Russian Society and Culture and the Long Eighteenth Century: Essays in Honour of Antony G. Cross. Műnster, Lit, pp. 62‒71.

Karp, S. Ya., Mel’yantsev, V. A. (2013). Vvedenie: Vostok I Zapad v XVIII veke [Introduction: East and West in the 18th Century]. In Vsemirnaya istoriya v 6 t. [World History. 6 Vols.]. Moscow, Nauka. Vol. 4. Mir v XVIII veke, pp. 5‒11.

Kashtanov, S. M. (1992). O tipe russkogo gosudarstva v XIV‒XVI vv. [On the Typology of the Russian State in the 14th‒16th Centuries]. In Chteniya pamyati V. B. Kobrina: “Problemy otechestvennoi istorii i kul’tury perioda feodalizma”. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Rossiiskogo gosudarstvennogo gumanitranogo universiteta, pp. 85‒92.

Kashtanov, S. M. (1999). Istoricheskie paralleli: Ivan III i Carl Martell [Historical Parallels: Ivan III and Carl Martell]. In Rossiya v IX‒XX v.: Problemy istorii, istoriografii I istochnikovedeniya [Russia in the 9‒20th Centuries: Issues of History, Historiography, and Source Studies]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Rossiiskogo gosudarstvennogo gumanitranogo universiteta, pp. 180–181.

Kivelson, V. (1996). Autocracy in the Provinces: The Muscovite Gentry and Political Culture in the Seventeenth Century. Cornell Univ. Press. 372 p.

Kivelson, V. (2006). Cartographies of Tsardom: The Land and Its Meanings in Seventeenth-Century Russia. Ithaca, N. Y., Cornell Univ. Press. 263 p.

Kivelson, V. (2012). Kartografiya tsarstva. Zemlya i ee znachenie v XVII v. [Cartographies of Tsardom. The Land and Its Meanings in 17th Century Russia]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 357 p.

Kollmann, N. S. (1999). By Honor Bound. State and Society in Early Modern Russia. Cornell Univ. Press. Ithaca, L., Cornell Univ. Press. 296 p.

Kollmann, N. S. (2002). Soedinennye chest’yu [Bound by Honour]. Moscow, Drevlekhranilishche. 461 p.

Kollmann, N. S. (2012). Crime and Punishment in Early Modern Russia. Cambridge, Cambridge Univ. Press. 488 p.

Kollmann, N. S. (2016). Prestuplenie i nakazanie v Rossii rannego Novogo vremeni [Crime and Punishment in Early Modern Russia]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 611 p.

Koval’chenko, I. D. (1995). Teoretiko-metodologicheskie problem istoricheskikh issledovanii [Theoretical and Methodological Issues of Historical Studies]. In Novaya i noveishaya istoriya. No. 1, pp. 3‒33.

Krom, M. M. (2015). Vvedenie v istoricheskuyu komparativistiku [An Introduction to Comparative History]. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge. 247 p.

Kukulin, I. V. (2017). V teni zavtrashnego dnya. Sezon 2. Seriya 24 [In the Shadow of Tomorrow. Season 2. Episode 24]. In Ab Imperio. No. 2, pp. 225‒255.

Malinova, O. Yu. (2012). Obshchestvo, publika, obshchestvennost’ v Rossii serediny XIX – nachala XX veka: Otrazhenie v ponyatiyah praktik publichnoi kommunikatsii i obshchestvennoi deyatel’nosti [Society and the Public in Russia between the mid‑19th and Early 20th Centuries: Notions of Public Communications and Public Activities Practices]. In “Ponyatiya o Rossii”. K istoricheskoi semantike imperskogo perioda v 2 t. Vol. 1. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, pp. 428‒463.

Martin, J. (1997). “Backwardness” in Russian Peasant Culture. A Theoretical Consideration of Agricultural Practices in the Seventeenth Century. In Baron, S. H., Kollmann, N. S. (Eds.). Religion and Culture in Early Modern Russia and Ukraine. DeKalb, Northern Illinois Univ. Press, pp. 19‒33.

Martin, T. D. (2001). The Affirmative Action Empire: Nations and Nationalism in the Soviet Union, 1923‒1939. Ithaca, N. Y., Cornell Univ. Press. 496 p.

Mezhuev V. M. (1997). Rossiya vse eshche v puti [Russia is still on the Way]. In Rodina. No. 9, pp. 10‒15.

Mif o vekovoi otstalosti Rossii [The Myth of Russian Backwardness]. (N. d.). In Rukspert. Spravochnik patriota [website]. URL: http://ruxpert.ru/ Миф_о_вековой_отсталости_России (mode of access: 24.10.2017).

Migdal, J. (1988). Strong Societies and Weak States: State-Society Relations and State Capabilities in the Third World. Princeton, Princeton Univ. Press. 296 p.

Miller, A. I. (2003). Predislovie [Preface]. In Wolff, L. Izobretaya Vostochnuyu Evropu: karta tzivilisatsii v soznanii epohi Prosvesheniya. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, pp. 5‒11.

Milov, L. V. (1998). Velikorusskyi pahar’ i osobennosti rossiiskogo istorichesko protsessa [The Great Russian Ploughman and the Peculiarities of the Russian Historical Process]. Moscow, ROSSPEN. 573 p.

Mironov, B. N. (1999). Sotsial’naya istoriya Rossii perioda imperii (XVIII ‒ nachalo XX v.). Genezis lichnosti, demokraticheskoi sem’i, grazhdanskogo obshchestva i pravovogo gosudarstva v 2 t. [The Social History of Russia of the Period of the Empire (18th ‒ Early 20th Centuries). The Genesis of an Individual, Democratic Family, Civil Society and the Rule of Law. 2 Vols.]. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin. 548 + 566 p.

Mironov, B. N. (1999‒2000). A Social History of Imperial Russia, 1700‒1917. 2 Vols. Boulder, Colo, Westview Press. 600 + 300 p.

Mironov, B. N. (2012). Blagosostoyanie naseleniya i rovolyutsii v imperskoi Rossii. XVIII – nachalo XX veka [The Wealth of the Population and Revolutions in Imperial Russia. 18th – Early 20th Centuries]. Moscow, Ves’ mir. 844 p.

Neumann, I. B. (1999). Uses of the Other. “The East” in European Identity Formation. Minneapolis, Univ. of Minnesota Press. 281 p.

Poe, M. (2000). A People Born to Slavery: Russia in Early Modern European Ethnography, 1476‒1748. Ithaca, N. Y., Cornell Univ. Press. 293 p.

Schenk, F. B. (2016). Poezd v sovremennost’. Mobil’nost’ i sotsial’noe prosrtanstvo v Rossii v vek zheleznykh dorog [A Train to Modernity. Mobility, and Social Space in Russia in the Railway Age]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 584 p.

Stalin, I. V. (1951). O zadachakh khozyaistvennikov. Rech na Pervoi Vsesoyuznoi konferentsii rabotnikov sotsialisticheskoi promyshlennosty 4 fevralya 1931 g. [On the Goals of Economy Executives. A Speech at the First All-Union Conference of the Workers of Socialist Industry on February 4, 1931]. In Stalin, I. V. Sochineniya v 13 t. Vol. 13. Moscow, Gospolitizdat, pp. 29‒42.

Stanziani, A. (2014). Russian Serfdom: A Reappraisal. In Ab Imperio. No. 2, pp. 71‒98.

Todorova, M. (1997). Imagining the Balkans. N. Y., Oxford Univ. Press. 257 p.

Todorova, M. (2005). The Trap of Backwardness: Modernity, Temporality, and the Study of Eastern European Nationalism. In Slavic Rev. Vol. 64. Spring. No. 1, pp. 140‒164.

Trotskii, L. D. (1931). Istoriya russkoi revolyutsii v 2 t. [The History of the Russian Revolution. 2 Vols.]. Vol. 1. Berlin, Granit. 531 p.

Ustryalov, N. G. (1858). Istoriya Petra Velikogo [The Story of Peter the Great]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya Vtorogo otdeleniya Sobstvennoi Ego Imperatorskogo Velichestva kantselyarii. 399 p.

Wolff, L. (1994). Inventing Eastern Europe. The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment. Calif., Stanfod Univ. Press. 419 p.

Wolff, L. (2003). Izobretaya Vostochnuyu Evropu: karta tzivilisatsii v soznanii epohi Prosvesheniya [Inventing Eastern Europe. The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 560 p.

Zhukovskii, V. A. (2008). Iz dnevnika [From the Diary]. In Fil’kina, E. Yu. (Ed.). “Put’ moi lezhit po zemle k prekrasnoi I vozvyshennoi tseli”. Moscow, Russkii mir, pp. 360–425.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/qr.2018.1.290

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 2311-911X (Print)
ISSN 2313-6871 (Online)

 

BASE Search eLibrary WorldCat