Contemporary Russian Historiography on the Pre-Petrine Era: New Aspects

Olga Kosheleva

Abstract


This review focuses on the most remarkable works in contemporary Russian historiography from recent decades on the pre-Petrine seventeenth century. Consciously ignoring the literature dedicated to diplomacy and war because of the sheer size of the available material, the author isolates questions connected with the socio-political and cultural development of the Muscovite state and society. In particular, she examines works looking at the intensity and direction of pre-Petrine Russia’s socio-cultural contacts with the West and the Orthodox East and the extent of their influence on the country’s historical development. Noting how the exhaustion of Marxist methodology (in its Soviet variant) has led contemporary Russian historiography to revive the opposition of the Slavophiles and Westernisers, the author nevertheless emphasises its new foundations, which are based on different methodological principles. There has been a shift of scholarly interest away from the ‘base’ to the ‘superstructure’ (to use the old Soviet terminology): now dominant is the attention placed on the discursive practices of the epoch and on the problems of intellectual history, the history of personhood, the network-actor interactions that created the fabric of social and cultural reality, and the increasing need to study the sources. The article’s main conclusion is that the varied (and sometimes mutually exclusive) interpretations of the meaning and significance of the cultural changes in the second half of the seventeenth century can scarcely be reduced to some generalising representation of the epoch. This will require the further accumulation and interpretation of empirical materials in the framework of new research paradigms. It is necessary to understand this period as part of an integral whole with the era of the Petrine reforms.


Keywords


historiography; innovation; cultural transfer; traditional culture; modernity; Modern era; transition period; dead-ends of development; reforms

References


Alpatov, M. A. (1976). Russkaya istoricheskaya mysl’ i Zapadnaya Evropa. XVII – pervaya chetvert’ XVIII v. [Russian Historical Thought and Western Europe. 17th – First Quarter of 18th Centuries]. Moscow, Nauka. 455 p.

Anisimov, E. V. (1997). Gosudarstvennye preobrazovaniya i samoderzhavie Petra Velikogo [State Transformations and Autocracy of Peter the Great]. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin. 331 p.

Anisimov, E. V. (2007). Pochemu Petr? Byla li al'ternativa dlya Rossii? [Why Peter? Was there an Alternative for Russia?]. In Rodina. No. 11, pp. 2–4.

Bogdanov, A. P. (2003). Konets “Tret’ego Rima” i utverzhdenie imperskogo samosoznaniya nakanune krusheniya moskovskogo tsarstva [The End of ‘The Third Rome’ and the Formation of Imperial Consciousness on the Eve of the Collapse of the Tsardom of Muscovy]. In Kiseleva, M. S. (Ed.). Chelovek mezhdu tsarstvom i imperiei. Sbornik materialov mezhdunarodnoi konferentsii. Moscow, Institut cheloveka RAN, pp. 47–59.

Bogdanov, A. P. (2012). Stikh torzhestva. Rozhdenie russkoi ody. Poslednyaya chetvert’ XVII–XVIII vv. v 2 ch. [The Verse of Triumph. The Birth of the Russian Ode. Last Quarter of the 17th – 18th Centuries. 2 Parts]. Moscow, Institut rossiiskoi istorii RAN. 380 + 296 p.

Bragone, M. C. (2008). Alfavitar radi učenija malych detej. Un abbecedario nella Russia del Seicento. Firenze, Firenze Univ. Press. 288 p.

Buseva-Davydova, I. L. (2005). Rossiya XVII veka: kul’tura i iskusstvo v epokhu peremen [Russia in the 17th Century. Culture and Art during the Epoch of Changes]. Avtoref. dis. … dokt. iskusstvovedeniya. Moscow, S. n. 48 p.

Buseva-Davydova, I. L. (2008). Kul’tura i iskusstvo v epokhu peremen. Rossiya XVII stoletiya [Culture and Art during the Epoch of Changes. Russia of the 17th Century]. Moscow, Indrik. 364 p.

Chernaya, L. A. (1999). Osnovnye problemy izucheniya russkoi kul’tury perekhodnogo perioda [The Basic Issues of Studying Russian Culture in a Transition Period]. In Chernaya, L. A. Russkaya kul’tura perekhodnogo perioda ot Srednevekov’ya k Novomu vremeni. Filosofsko-antropologicheskii analiz russkoi kul’tury XVII – pervoi treti XVIII v. Moscow, Yazyki russkoi kul’tury, pp. 13–29.

Chernaya, L. A. (2008). Antropologicheskii kod drevnerusskoi kul’tury [The Anthropological Code of Old Russian Culture]. Moscow, Yazyki slavyanskoi kul’tury. 463 p.

Chernaya, L. A. (2012). Russkie v perelomnuyu epokhu ot Srednevekov’ya k Novomu vremeni. Uchebnoe posobie [Russians during the Transition Epoch from the Middle Ages to the Modern Era. A Textbook]. Moscow, Logos. 248 p.

Chesnokova, N. P. (2011). Khristianskii Vostok i Rossiya: politicheskoe i kul’turnoe vzaimodeistvie v seredine XVII veka (po dokumentam RGADA) [The Christian East and Russia. Political and Cultural Interaction in the Mid‑17th Century (with Reference to RGADA Documents)]. Moscow, Indrik. 288 p.

Demin, A. S. (1977). Russkaya literatura vtoroi poloviny XVII – nachala XVIII v.: novye khudozhestvennye predstavleniya o mire, prirode, cheloveke [The Russian Literature of the 2nd Half of the 17th – Early 18th Centuries. New Artistic Ideas of the World, Nature, and Man]. Moscow, Nauka. 296 p.

Demkin, A. V. (1992). Zapadnoevropeiskie kuptsy i ikh prikazchiki v Rossii XVII veka [The West European Merchants and their Salesmen in 17th-Century Russia]. Moscow, S. n. 55 p.

Dergacheva, I. V. (2003). “Lekarstvo dushevnoe” kak pamyatnik religioznoi antropologicheskoi literatury [Spiritual Remedy as an Artefact of Religious Anthropological Literature]. In Kiseleva, M. S. (Ed.). Chelovek mezhdu tsarstvom i imperiei. Sbornik materialov mezhdunarodnoi konferentsii. Moscow, Institut cheloveka RAN, pp. 379–389.

Eskin, Yu. M. (2013). Dmitrii Mikhailovich Pozharskii [Dmitry Mikhailovich Pozharsky]. Moscow, Kvadriga, Zebra E. 352 p.

Fonkich, B. L. (2009). Greko-slavyanskie shkoly v Moskve v XVII veke [Graeco-Slavic Schools in 17th-Century Moscow]. Moscow, Yazyki slavyanskoi kul’tury. 339 p.

Fonkich, B. L. (2012). O sovremennykh metodakh issledovaniya grecheskikh i russkikh dokumentov XVII veka. Kriticheskie zametki [On Modern Methods of Researching the Greek and Russian Documents of the 17th Century. Critical Notes]. Moscow, Yazyki slavyanskoi kul’tury. 184 p.

Hughes, L. (1998). Russia in the Age of Peter the Great. N. Haven, L., Yale Univ. Press. 640 p.

Ioann, (Ekonomtsev), Father Superior. (1992). Pravoslavie. Vizantiya. Rossiya. Sbornik statei [Orthodoxy. Byzantium. Russia. A Collection of Articles]. Moscow, Khristianskaya literatura. 238 p.

Kamenskii, A. B. (2001). Ot Petra I do Pavla I [From Peter I to Paul I]. Moscow, Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi gumanitarnyi universitet. 575 p.

Klyuchevskii, V. O. (1957). Sochineniya v 8 t. [Works. 8 Vols.]. Moscow, Gospolitizdat. Vol. 1. Kurs russkoi istorii. Part 1. 425 p.

Korzo, M. A. (2007). Ukrainskaya i belorusskaya katekheticheskaya traditsiya kontsa XVII–XVIII v. [The Ukrainian and Belarusian Catechetic Tradition of the Late 17th – 18th Centuries]. Moscow, Kanon+. 672 p.

Korzo, M. A. (2011). Nravstvennoe bogoslovie Simeona Polotskogo: osvoenie katolicheskoi traditsii moskovskimi knizhnikami vtoroi poloviny XVII v. [Simeon of Polotsk’s Moral Theology. The Development of the Catholic Tradition by Moscow Scribes of the Second Half of the 17th Century]. Moscow, Institut filosofii RAN. 155 p.

Košeleva, O. E. (2015). La Storiographia Russa Moderna sull’epocca pre-petrina (secolo XVII): problemi, metodi, orientamendi. In Acme, no. 1, pp. 83–98. DOI: http://dx.doi.org.10.13130/2282–0035/5137.

Kosheleva, O. E. (2007). Izuchenie petrovskikh reform v ramkakh raznykh paradigm [The Study of Petrine Reforms within the Framework of Different Paradigms]. In Goncharov, Yu. M. (Ed.). IV nauchnye chteniya pamyati Yu. S. Bulygina. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Barnaul, Izdatel’stvo Altaiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, pp. 22–32.

Kosheleva, O. E., Nasedkin, E. N. (2013). Fenomen reform v XVII stoletii v Rossii i ikh interpretatsiya v XVIII veke [The Phenomenon of Reforms in 17th-Century Russia and Their Interpretation in the 18th Century]. In Krom, M. M., Pimenova, L. A. (Eds.). Fenomen reform na zapade i vostoke Evropy v nachale Novogo vremeni (XVI–XVIII vv.). [The Phenomenon of Reform in Western and Eastern Europe at the Beginning of the Modern Period (16th to 18th Centuries)]. St Petersburg, Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskii universitet, pp. 179–191.

Kovrigina, V. A. (1998). Nemetskaya sloboda Moskvy i ee zhiteli v kontse XVII – XVIII vv. [The German Quarter of Moscow and Its Inhabitants at the End of the 17th – 18th Centuries]. Moscow, Arkheograficheskii tsentr. 440 p.

Krasnobaev, B. I. (1983). Russkaya kul’tura vtoroi poloviny XVII – nachala XIX v. [The Russian Culture of the Second Half of the 17th – Early 19th Centuries]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta. 224 p.

Kristensen, S. (1989). Istoriya Rossii XVII v. [The History of 17th-Century Russia]. Moscow, Progress. 256 p.

Likhachev, D. S. (1973). Razvitie russkoi literatury X–XVII vekov. Epokhi i stili [The Development of Russian Literature between the 10th and 17th Centuries. Epochs and Styles]. Leningrad, Nauka. 254 p.

Likhachev, D. S. (1988). XVII vek v russkoi literature [The 17th Century in Russian Literature]. In Pamyatniki literatury Drevnei Rusi. XVII v. Book 1. Moscow, Khudozhestvennaya literatura, pp. 6–26.

Liseitsev, D. V. (2003). Posol’skii prikaz v epokhu Smuty v 2 t. [The Ambassadorial Prikaz during the Time of Troubles. 2 Vols.]. Moscow, Institut rossiiskoi istorii RAN. 264 + 219 p.

Liseitsev, D. V. (2009). Prikaznaya sistema Moskovskogo gosudarstva v epokhu Smuty [The Prikaz System of the Tsardom of Muscovy during the Time of Troubles]. Moscow, Institut rossiiskoi istorii RAN, Tula, Grif i K°. 788 p.

Murav’ev, A. V., Sakharov, A. M. (1984). Ocherki istorii russkoi kul’tury XI–XVII vv. Kniga dlya uchitelya [Essays on the History of Russian Culture of the 11th – 17th Centuries. Teacher’s Book]. Moscow, Prosveshchenie. 336 p.

Nikolaev, S. I. (2008). Pol’sko-russkie literaturnye svyazi XVI–XVIII vv. Bibliograficheskie materialy [Polono-Russian Literary Communications between the 16th and 18th Centuries. Bibliographic Materials]. St Petersburg, Nestor-istoriya. 248 p.

Oparina, T. A. (2007). Inozemtsy v Rossii XVI–XVII vv. Ocherki istoricheskoi biografii i genealogii [Foreigners in Russia between the 16th and 17th Centuries. Essays on Historical Biography and Genealogy]. Moscow, Progress&Traditsiya. 384 p.

Orlenko, S. P. (2004). Vykhodtsy iz Zapadnoi Evropy v Rossii XVII v. (pravovoi status i real’noe polozhenie) [Western Europeans in 17th-Century Russia (Legal Status and Real Position)]. Moscow, Drevlekhranilishche. 344 p.

Panich, T. V. (1996). Literaturnoe tvorchestvo Afanasiya Kholmogorskogo [Athanasius of Kholmogory’s Literary Heritage]. Novosibirsk, Sibirskii khronograf. 210 p.

Prilezhaev, E. M. (1881). Shkol’noe delo v Rossii do Petra Velikogo i v nachale XVIII v. [Schools in Russia before Peter the Great and in the Early 18th Century]. In Strannik. No. 1, pp. 1–25. No. 2, pp. 195–218. No. 3, pp. 387–407.

Robinson, A. N. (1974). Bor’ba idei v russkoi literature XVII v. [The Struggle of Ideas in the Russian Literature of the 17th Century]. Moscow, Nauka. 407 p.

Rybalko, N. B. (2011). Rossiiskaya prikaznaya byurokratiya v Smutnoe vremya. Nachalo XVII v. [Russian Prikaz Bureaucracy in the Time of Troubles. Early 17th Century]. Moscow, Kvadriga, MBA. 656 p.

Sakharov, A. M. (1979). Rossiya i ee kul’tura v XVII stoletii [Russia and Its Culture in the 17th Century]. In Ocherki russkoi kul’tury XVII v. v 2 ch. [Essays on 17th-Century Russian Culture. 2 Parts]. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta. Part 1. Material’naya kul’tura. Gosudarstvennyi stroi, pp. 5–24.

Sapozhnikova, O. S. (2010). Russkii knizhnik XVII veka Sergei Shelonin [The 17th-Century Russian Scribe Sergey Shelonin]. Moscow, St Petersburg, Al’yans-Arkheo. 560 p.

Sedov, P. V. (2006). Zakat Moskovskogo tsarstva [The Decline of the Tsardom of Muscovy]. St Petersburg, Dmitrii Bulanin. 604 p.

Shamin, S. M. (2011). Kuranty XVII stoletiya. Evropeiskaya pressa v Rossii i vozniknovenie russkoi periodicheskoi pechati [The Chiming Clock of the 17th Century. The European Press in Russia and the Emergence of Russian Periodicals]. Moscow, Al’yans-Arkheo. 352 p.

Sharf, K. (2008). Monarkhiya, osnovannaya na zakone, vmesto despotii. Transfer i adaptatsiya evropeiskikh idei i evolyutsiya vozzrenii na gosudarstvo v Rossii v epokhu Prosveshcheniya [A Monarchy Based on Law instead of Despotism. The Transfer and Adaptation of European Ideas and the Evolution of Views on the State in Russia during the Era of Enlightenment]. In Doronin, A. V. (Ed.). “Vvodya nravy i obychai Evropeiskie v Evropeiskom narode”. K probleme adaptatsii zapadnykh idei i praktik v Rossiiskoi imperii. Moscow, ROSSPEN, pp. 9–45.

Solov’ev, S. M. (1961). Istoriya Rossii s drevneishikh vremen v 15 kn. [The History of Russia from the Ancient Times. 15 Books]. Moscow, Sotsekgiz, Mysl’. Book 6. Vol. 11–12. 682 p.

Stefanovich, P. S., Morozov, B. N. (2009). Roman Vilimovich v gostyakh u Petra Ignat’evicha: pskovskii arkhiv angliiskogo kuptsa 1680-kh godov [Roman Vilimovich Visiting Pyotr Ignatyevich. The Pskov Archive of an English Merchant of the 1680s]. Moscow, Indrik. 176 p.

Timoshina, L. A. (2010). O nauchnoi biografii Andreya Andreevicha Viniusa: retsenziya [On A. A. Vinius’s Academic Biography. A Review]. In Ocherki feodal’noi Rossii. Iss. 14. Moscow, St Petersburg, Al’yans-Arkheo, pp. 530–557.

Tokarev, V. A. (2009). Vozvrashchenie na p’edestal: tema russkoi Smuty v sotsiokul’turnom kontekste 1930-kh gg. [Returning to the Pedestal. The Theme of the Russian Time of Troubles in the Sociocultural Context of the 1930s]. In Den’ narodnogo edinstva: Biografiya prazdnika. Moscow, Drofa, pp. 303–335.

Yurkin, I. N. (2007). Andrei Andreevich Vinius, 1641–1716 [Andrey Andreevich Vinius, 1641–1716]. Moscow, Nauka. 558 p.

Zabelin, I. E. (1886). Pervoe vodvorenie v Moskve grekolatinskoi i obshchei evropeiskoi nauki [The First Introduction of Graeco-Latin and General European Science in Moscow]. In Chteniya v Imperatorskom obshchestve istorii i drevnostei Rossiiskikh pri Moskovskom universitete. Oktyabr’-Dekabr’. Book 4, pp. 7–30.

Zhivov, V. M. (2000). Religioznaya reforma i individual’noe nachalo v russkoi literature XVII v. [Religious Reform and Individualism in Russian Literature of the 17th Century]. In Iz istorii russkoi kul’tury v 5 t. [From the History of Russian Culture. 5 Vols.]. Moscow, Yazyki russkoi kul’tury. Vol. 3. XVII – nachalo XVIII v., pp. 460–485.

Zhivov, V. M. (2001). Zametki o vizantiiskoi kul’ture v Rossii rannego novogo vremeni [Notes on Byzantine Culture in Russia in the Early Modern Period]. In Russia medievalis. Vol. 10. No. 1. München, Wilhelm Fink, pp. 325–344.

Zhivov, V. M. (2004). Iz tserkovnoi istorii vremen Petra Velikogo. Issledovaniya i materialy [From the Church History of the Epoch of Peter the Great. Studies and Materials]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 368 p.

Zhivov, V. M. (2004). Ob istoricheskoi nauke u Karlo Ginzburga [On Historical Science in Carlo Ginzburg’s Works]. In Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. No. 2. URL: http://magazines.russ.ru/nlo/2004/65/zh1.html (mode of access: 10.09.2017).




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/qr.2018.1.295

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 2311-911X (Print)
ISSN 2313-6871 (Online)

 

BASE Search eLibrary WorldCat