Factors, Mechanisms, and Resources for Stable Russian Control over Little Russia (The Second Half of the 17th Century)

Yakov Lazarev

Abstract


The author demonstrates that the existing historical and sociological models explaining the peculiarities of control over the region by means of military forces and centralised bureaucracy, which exercised repressive management practices in relation to local (national) elites, do not correlate with real historical practices. According to the tsarist government’s initial plans, local self-governing corporations (the Zaporozhye Registry Army and cities that were self-governing according to Magdeburg Rights) were to be the main resources for holding sustainable control over the region, including as intermediaries in tax collection. The article notes that this trend intensified during the geopolitical competition over Little Russia (with the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, the Crimean Khanate, and Ottoman Turkey) and as a consequence of the political instability within the Cossack elites and the financial crisis of 1662. As a result, the Russian state could not fully financially support the few enclaves of tsarist (voivoda) administration in the region. Referring to the history of Russian institutions in the region (voivoda offices) in the 1670s–1690s, the author demonstrates the reasons which prevented the tsar’s agents from keeping the region under control and resisting unrest. The article notes that for the sake of preserving even such limited control and maintaining the loyalty of the Cossack elite, the tsarist government did not collect taxes from the local population between 1669 and 1722.


Keywords


Russian state; Little Russia; Hetmanate; Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth; Magdeburg Rights; voivode authority; empire; control mechanisms

References


AYuZR [Acts Relating to the History of Southern and Western Russia]. Vol. 6, 7, 8.

Babulin, I. B. (2015a). Bor’ba za Ukrainu i bitva pod Konotopom (1658–1659 gg.) [The Struggle for Ukraine and the Battle of Konotop (1658–1659)]. Moscow, Russkie vityazi. 399 p.

Babulin, I. B. (2015b). Kanevskaya bitva 16 iyulya 1662 g. [The Battle of Kaniv, 16 July 1662]. Moscow, Russkie Vityazi, 85 p.

Bantysh-Kamenskii, D. N., Bodyanskii, O. (Eds.). (1858). Istochniki malorossiiskoi istorii v 2 ch. [Sources of Little Russian History. 2 Parts]. Moscow, Universitetskaya tipografiya. Part 1. 340 p.

Bazilevich, K. V. (1936). Denezhnaya reforma Alekseya Mikhailovicha i vosstanie v Moskve v 1662 godu [Alexei Mikhailovich’s Monetary Reform and the Uprising in Moscow in 1662]. Moscow, Leningrad, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. 120 p.

Bohun, T., Małow, A., Smirnowa, O. (2015). Materiały wywiadu moskiewskiego o wojskowo-politycznej sytuacji w Rzeczypospolitej w pierwszej połowie 1630 r. (Dokumenty Urzędu Wojskowego dotyczące powstania Tarasa Fedorowicza na Ukrainie wiosną 1630 r. z zespołukolekcji RGADA «Akta urzędowe nowego uporządkowania»). In Klio. Vol. 2 (25), ss. 218‒252.

Bordyugov, G., Bukharaev, V. (2011). Vcherashnee zavtra: kak “natsional’nye istorii” pisalis’ v SSSR i kak pishutsya teper’ [Yesterday’s Tomorrow: How “National Histories” were Written in the USSR and how they are Written now]. Moscow, AIRO-XXI. 247 p.

Butich, І., Rinsevich, V., Teslenko, І., (Eds.). (2004). Universali ukraїns’kikh getmaniv vid Ivana Vigovs’kogo do Ivana Samoilovicha (1657–1687) [Universals of Ukrainian Hetmans from Ivan Vyhovsky to Ivan Samoilovych (1657–1687)]. Kiїv, L’viv, Naukove tovaristvo іmenі Shevchenka. 1118 p.

Florya, B. N. (2010). Russkoe gosudarstvo i ego zapadnye sosedi (1655–1661 gg.) [The Russian State and Its Western Neighbours (1655–1661)]. Moscow, Indrik. 656 p.

Florya, B. N. (2013). Vneshnepoliticheskaya programma A. L. Ordina-Nashchokina i popytki ee osushchestvleniya [The Foreign Policy Programme of A. L. Ordin-Nashchokin and Attempts to Implement it]. Moscow, Indrik. 447 p.

Fominov, A. V. (2013). Valuiskoe razorenie 1633 g. [The Valuyki Devastation of 1633.]. In Staryi tseikhgauz. No. 52, pp. 76–83.

Gordon, P. (2003). Dnevnik, 1659–1667 [Diary, 1659–1667]. Moscow, Nauka. 314 p.

Gorobets’, V. (2013). “Chorna rada” 1663 roku. Peredumovi, rezul’tati, naslіdki [“The Black Council” in 1663. Prerequisites, Results, Consequences]. Kiїv, Іnstitut іstorії Ukraїni. 200 p.

Kamins’kii, A. S. (2011). Istoriya Rechi Pospolitoї yak istoriya bagat’okh narodiv, 1505–1795. Gromadyani, їkhnya derzhava, suspil’stvo, kul’tura [The History of the Commonwealth as a Story of Many Nations, 1505–1795. Citizens, Their State, Society, Culture]. Kiїv, Nash chas. 266 p.

Kas’yanov, G. N., Miller, A. I. (2011). Rossiya – Ukraina: kak pishetsya istoriya. Dialogi – lektsii – stat’i [Russia ‒ Ukraine: How They Write History. Dialogues ‒ Lectures ‒ Articles]. Moscow, Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi gumanitarnyi universitet. 311 p.

Kiselev, M. A. (2015). State Metallurgy Factories and Direct Taxes in the Urals, 1700–50: Paths to State Building in Early Modern Russia. In Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. Vol. 16. No. 1 (Winter), pp. 7–36.

Kisil’, I. M. (2006). Sotsіal’no-ekonomіchne stanovishche mіshchan Get’manshchini (druga polovina XVII – druga polovina XVIII st.) [The Socio-Economic Position of Burghers of the Hetmanate (Second Half of the 17th –Second Half of the 18th Centuries)]. Dis. … kandidata istoricheskikh nauk. Kiїv, S. n. 222 p.

Kivelson, V. (2012). Kartografiya tsarstva. Zemlya i ee znacheniya v Rossii XVII veka [Cartographies of the Tsardom. The Land and Its Meaning in 17th-Century Russia]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 360 p.

Kivelson, V. A., Suny, R. G. (2017). Russia’s Empires. N. Y., Oxford, Oxford Univ. Press. 420 p.

Kołodziejczyk, D. (1994). Podole pod panowaniem tureckim. Ejalet Kamieniecki, 1672–1699 rr. Warszawa, Polczek. 256 s.

Kozlyakov, V. N. (2010). Mikhail Fedorovich. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya. 344 p.

Kroll, P. (2008). Od ugody hadziackiej do Cudnowa. Kozaczyzna między Rzecząpospolitą a Moskwą w latach 1658–1660. Warszawa, Wydawnictwa Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego. 452 p.

Kulakovs’kii, P. (2006). Chernigovo-Sivershchishchna u skladi Rechipospolitoї (1618–1648) [Chernihiv Severia as Part of the Commonwealth (1618–1648)]. Kiїv, Tempora. 496 p.

Lazarev, J. (2014). Odnodvortsy v sisteme pryamogo nalogooblozheniya Rossii XVIII v.: K voprosu o roli nekoronnykh agentov v upravlenii gosudarstvom rannego Novogo vremeni [Odnodvortsy and Direct Taxation in 18th-Century Russia: The Role of Non-State Tax Collectors during the Early Modern Period]. In Cahiers du monde russe. Vol. 55. No. 3–4, pp. 215–234.

Lazarev, Ya. A. (2016). «Ne-kanonichnye» versii istorii Ukrainy vtoroi poloviny XVII–XVIII v. v novykh istoricheskikh kursakh [Examining the New Historical Courses Describing the Non-Canonical History of Ukraine during the Second Half of the 17th ‒ 18th Centuries]. In Istoricheskii vestnik. Vol. 16 (163), pp. 192–221.

Miller, A. I. (2006). Imperiya Romanovykh i natsionalizm [The Romanov Empire and Nationalism]. Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 240 p.

Moldovan, A. M., Maier, I. (Eds.). (2009). Vesti-Kuranty. 1656 g., 1660–1662 gg., 1664–1670 gg.: russkie teksty [Vesti-Kuranty. 1656, 1660‒1662, 1664–1670: Russian Texts]. Moscow, Rukopisnye pamyatniki Drevnei Rusi. Part 1. 856 p.

Papkov, A. I. (2004). Porubezh’e Rossiiskogo tsarstva i ukrainskikh zemel’ Rechi Pospolitoi (konets XVI – pervaya polovina XVII veka) [The Borderlands of the Russian Kingdom and the Ukrainian Lands of the Commonwealth (Late 16th – First Half of the 17th Centuries)]. Belgorod, Konstanta. 351 p.

Perdenia, J. (2000). Hetman Piotr Doroszenko a Polska. Kraków, Universitas. 502 p.

RGADA [The Russian State Archive of Ancient Acts]. Stock 137. List 2. Dos. 192, 236; Stock 210. Stolbtsy Belgorodskogo stola. Dos. 153; Stock 229. List 1. Dos. 100, 117, 120, 153, 158, 174, 212; Stock 396. List 3. Dos. 19.

Romanovskii, V. A. (1967). Perepis’ naseleniya Levoberezhnoi Ukrainy 1666 goda: ee organizatsiya i kriticheskaya otsenka [The Census of Left-Bank Ukraine in 1666: Its Organisation and Critical Evaluation]. Stavropol’, N. d. 125 p.

Shevchenko, F. P. (2014). Іstorichnі studії: zbіrka vibranikh prats’ і materіalіv (Do 100-rіchchya vіd dnya narodzhennya) [Historical Studies: A Collection of Selected Works and Materials (100th Birthday)]. Kiїv, Іnstitut іstorіi Ukraїni. 700 p.

Smolii, V. A. (Ed.). (2018). Ukraїns’kii Get’manat: narisi іstorії natsіonal’nogo derzhavotvorennya XVII–XVIII st. u 2 kn. [Ukrainian Hetmanate: Essays on the History of the National State-Building of the 17th ‒ 18th Centuries. 2 Books]. Kiïv, Іnstitut іstorії Ukraїni NAN Ukraїni. Book 1. 610 p.

Smolii, V. A., Stepankov, V. S. (1995). Bogdan Khmel’nits’kii: sotsіal’no-polіtichnii portret [Bohdan Khmelnytsky: Socio-Political Portrait]. Kiїv, Libіd’. 624 p.

Tairova-Yakovleva, T. G. (2011). Ivan Mazepa i Rossiiskaya imperiya: istoriya “predatel’stva” [Ivan Mazepa and the Russian Empire: The Story of “Betrayal”]. Moscow, Tsentrpoligraf. 525 p.

Timofeev, A. I., Uspenskii, F. I. (Eds.). (1884). Russkaya istoricheskaya biblioteka, izdavaemaya Arkheograficheskoi komissiei v 39 t. [Russian Historical Library, Published by the Archaeological Commission. 39 Vols.]. St Petersburg, Tipografiya F. G. Elkovskogo i Ko. Vol. 8. 1400 stb.

Ukraїns’kii arkheografichnii zbirnik u 3 t. [Ukrainian Archaeographic Collection]. (1926). Kiїv, Drukarnya Vseukraїns’koi Akademiї Nauk. Vol. 1. 355 p.

Vossoedinenie Ukrainy s Rossiei. Dokumenty i materialy v 3 t. [Ukraine’s Reunification with Russia. Documents and Materials. 3 Vols.]. (1953). Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. Vol. 1. 588 p. Vol. 3. 646 p. (VUR).

Wójcik, Z. (1959). Traktat andruszowski 1667 roku i jego geneza. Warszawa, Państwowe Wydawn. Naukowe. 279 p.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/qr.2018.2.300

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 2311-911X (Print)
ISSN 2313-6871 (Online)

 

BASE Search eLibrary WorldCat