Pakistan: wither tax reforms — the case of large taxpayers’ unit, Islamabad

Muhammad Ashfaq Ahmed

Abstract


Pakistan tax system reforms carried out during 2001–2010, were overwhelming, expensive, and a failure. The reforms were financially afforded and technically assisted by World Bank. While both Government of Pakistan and World Bank agreed on the failure of tax reforms, each blamed the other for the failure. A consensus, however, does exist as regards the fact that the reform program left the tax system more gridlocked, retrofitted, and incapacitated than before to generate both sufficient and healthy revenues. The paper adopts case study approach to explore into the factors of failure of the reform program. The study is anchored in Large Taxpayers’ Unit, Islamabad — a flagship taxing field formation established under the reform project. The data are produced from Large Taxpayers’ Unit, Islamabad, to assess its jurisdictional, functional, and operational capacity and explain why its tax collection curve flattens after 2012. The insights so derived at micro-level are made to feed back into macro-canvass of the program and enhance our holistic understanding and see its failure in a different and closer-to-reality light. The analysis is extrapolated to the national level to argue that as soon as political ownership and donor oversight — the key drivers — were omitted from the equation, the resultant resource constrains were enough to frustrate and fail the entire reform program. The conclusions drawn are generalizable to most similarly-circumstanced developing countries and their rigidly underperforming tax systems.

Highlights

1. The evaluation of a tax reform program being essentially subjective could well be undertaken by adopting case study approach that generates empirics at micro-level, which get fed into the analytics at the macro-level

2. In order for the tax reform evaluation to stay comprehensively meaningful, it covers the micro locale being evaluated across its full spectrum i.e. jurisdictional, functional, and operational capacity

3. Continued political ownership and donor oversight are key variables of a tax reform program, and their elimination from the equation mid-stream potentially results in reversing and even perverting the entire reform agenda

 FOR CITATION

Ahmed M. A. Pakistan: wither tax reforms — the case of large taxpayers’ unit, Islamabad. Journal of Tax Reform, 2018, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 202–222. DOI: 10.15826/jtr.2018.4.3.052

ARTICLE INFO

Received August 30, 2018; accepted December 9, 2018


Keywords


Pakistan tax system; tax reforms; Large Taxpayers’ Unit; World Bank reforms; Federal Board of Revenue; tax administration

Full Text

PDF

References


Qazi R. S. Tax Administration Reform Project. NMC Individual Research Paper, 1-10, 2008. Available at: http://www.fbr.gov.pk
2. Haq I., Bukhari H. Tax Reforms. Business Recorder, 2012, March 30.
3. Ahmed M. A. Elites, Extraction, and State Autonomy: Pakistan and U.S in Comparison. Doct. Diss. Quaid-e-Azam University, 2015. Pp. 252–417.
4. Akhter S. Tax Reform Programme Failed to Deliver, Government Admits. The News, 2012, July 26.
5. Martinez-Vazquez J. M. Richter K. Pakistan’s Short and Medium Term Reform Options. In: Martinez-Vazquez J. M., Cyan M. R. (eds) The Role of Taxation in Pakistan’s Revival. Karachi, Oxford University Press, 2015. Pp. 549–684.
6. Grossman M. G., Helpman, E. Protection for Sale. American Economic Review, 1994, vol. 84, pp. 833–850.
7. Bird M. R. Administrative Dimensions of Tax Reforms in Developing Countries. In: Gillis M. (ed.) Tax Reforms in Developing Countries. Durham: Duke University Press, 1989. Pp. 315–346.
8. Gordon R. H., Li W. Tax Structure in Developing Countries: Many Puzzles and a Possible Explanation. Journal of Public Economics, 2009, vol. 93, no. 7-8, pp. 855–866. DOI: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2009.04.001.
9. Ahmad E., Stern N. H. The Theory and Practice of Tax Reform in Developing Countries. New York, Cambridge University Press, 1991. 344 p.
10. Stotsky J. Summary of Tax Policy Advice. In: Shome P. (ed.) Tax Policy Handbook. Washington DC, IMF, 1995. Pp. 279–283.
11. Klein N. The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. New York, Metropolitan Books, 2007. 726 p.
12. Burgess R., Stern N. Taxation and Development. London, LSE, 1992.
13. Orsmond D. W. H., Mackenzie G. A., Gerson P. The Composition of Fiscal Adjustment and Growth: lessons from fiscal reforms in eight economies. Washington DC, IMF, 1997. 72 p.
14. Ather R., Rider M. Pakistan’s Tax Gap: Estimates by Tax Collection and Methodology. Atlanta: Georgia State University, 2008.
15. Pasha H. A. Political Economy of Tax Reforms: The Pakistan Experience. Pakistan Journal of Applied Economics, 1995, vol. 11, no. 1-2, pp. 129–154. Available at: http://aerc.edu.pk/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/8th-Paper-Page-129-154c-1.pdf
16. Islam A. Issues in Tax Reforms. Asia Pacific Development Journal. 2001, vol. 8, no. 1. Available at: https://www.unescap.org/sites/default/files/apdj-8-1-1-ISLAM.pdf
17. Thirsk W. A Review of Major Taxes. In: Vazquez J. M., Cyan M. R. (ed.) The Role of Taxation in Pakistan’s Revival, Karachi, Oxford University Press, 2015. Pp. 78–117.
18. Wahid U., Wallace S. The Equity Debate in Tax Policy. In: Martinez-Vazquez J. M., Cyan M. R. (eds) The Role of Taxation in Pakistan’s Revival. Karachi, Oxford University Press, 2015. Pp. 255–336.
19. Michielse G. M. Tax Provisions and the Global Economy. Martinez-Vazquez J. M., Cyan M. R. (eds) The Role of Taxation in Pakistan’s Revival. Karachi, Oxford University Press, 2015. Pp. 209–254.
20. Ahmed M. A. Pakistan: Withholdingization of the Economic System. A Source of Revenue, Civil Strife or Dutch Disease+? Pakistan Development Review, 2018, vol. 57, no. 4, pp. 1–43.
21. Yasir, M. S.B.P Had to Spend Rs. 9.1 Billion on Printing Currency Notes Last Year, 2017. Available at: https://propakistani.pk/2017/11/01/sbp-spend-rs-9-1-billion-printing-currency-notes-last-year/
22. Alm J., Khan M. A. Tax Policy Effects on Business Incentives. In: Martinez-Vazquez J. M., Cyan M. R. (eds) The Role of Taxation in Pakistan’s Revival. Karachi, Oxford University Press, 2015. Pp. 142–248.
23. Ahmed M. A. Pakistan: Extraction, Elites and State Autonomy: A Theoretical Configuration. The Pakistan Development Review, 2017, vol. 56, no. 2, pp. 127–162.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/jtr.2018.4.3.052

Copyright (c) 2018 Muhammad Ashfaq Ahmed

eLibrary logoeLibrary logo  DOAJ logo ERIH PLUS logo 

© Journal of Tax Reform : ISSN 2414-9497 (online), ISSN 2412-8872 (print)