Tax burden reduction and tax cuts in China’s vat reform

Yong Fan, Haonan Li, Qinyao Zhu

Abstract


The article discusses the impact of VAT reforms in China aimed at reducing tax burden. These include the VAT transformation, “replacement of the business tax with the VAT”, and the simplification and consolidation of the tax rate. The purpose of our study is to describe the results of the VAT reforms and answer two questions: why is there so much controversy surrounding tax burden in the context of the “business tax to VAT” reform? and why are companies so concerned about the VAT reform? These questions can be answered if we analyze the four indicators of the VAT tax burden: the statutory tax rate, the effective tax rate, the nominal tax burden and the actual tax burden. These indicators can also be considered on three levels: macro-level (state or region), mid-level (industry), and micro-level (enterprises). The article illustrates the differences and relationships between these indicators and uses them to analyze the effect of the tax cuts. The input-output method is applied to analyze the indicators for the 2008–2015 period. All indicators of the VAT reform, except for the statutory tax rate, show a clear declining trend in terms of tax burden: the effective tax rate in various industries has dropped by about 1% to 10%; the nominal tax burden, by about 0.5–5%; the actual tax burden, by 150 billion yuan. Therefore, we recommend to reduce the VAT burden by establishing a VAT retained refund system and by increasing the actual deductible rate of enterprises.

For citation

Fan Y., Li H., Zhu Q. Tax burden reduction and tax cuts in China’s vat reform. Journal of Tax Reform. 2019;5(1):23–41. DOI: 10.15826/jtr.2019.5.1.058

Article info

Received July 7, 2018; accepted February 1, 2019

 


Keywords


value-added tax, VAT reform, business tax, statutory tax rate, effective tax rate, nominal tax burden, actual tax burden, input-output method

References


Fan Y. The tax cut reduction effect of VAT Reform in China. China Economic Weekly. 2017;19:74–77.
2. Keqiang L. Report on the Work of the Government. Delivered at the Fourth Session of the 12th National People’s Congress of People’s Republic of China on March 5, 2016. Available at: http://english.gov.cn/premier/news/2016/03/17/content_281475309417987.htm
3. Liu D. M., Zhang B. Q. Analysis of the Impact of “VAT Reform” on the Tax Burden of Commercial Banks. Taxation Research. 2015;(5):107–112.
4. Jiang M. Y. The Impact of VAT “Expansion” Reform on Industry Tax Burden – Based on the Analysis of Input-Output Table. Journal of Central University of Finance & Economics. 2011;(2):11–16.
5. Tian Z. W., Hu Y. J. Dynamic Analysis of the Impact of “Calculation Reform” on Tax Burden in Various Industries – Based on Analysis of CGE Model. Collected Essays on Finance and Economics. 2013;(4):29–34.
6. Tong J. Z., Su G. C., Wei Z. H. “Replacing the business tax with VAT” Reform, Enterprise Bargaining Power and Enterprise Actual Turnover Tax Burden – An Empirical Study Based on Chinese Listed Companies. Finance & Trade Economics. 2015;(11):14–26.
7. Chen X. G. Different Effective Tax rates of VAT and Efficiency Loss: With Some Implications for “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT”. Social Sciences in China. 2013;(8):67–84, 205–206.
8. Fan Z. Y., Peng F. The Tax Reduction Effect and Labor Division Effect of “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT”: Based on the Perspective of Industrial Interconnection. Economic Research Journal. 2017;52(2):82–95.
9. Wang Y. L., Li Y. K. Research on the Impact of “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT” on the Tax Burden and Profit Level of the Transportation Industry – Taking the Listed Companies in Shanghai as an Example. Public Finance Research. 2014;(5):41–45.
10. Huang G. L. Analysis of the Impact of “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT” on the Tax Burden of Transportation Enterprises. Finance & Accounting for Communications. 2013;(11):8–12.
11. Yang Z. Y. The Tax Burden Problem in the “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT”. China Finance and Economics Newspaper. 2012;(3).
12. Li X. C. Discussion on Tax Planning of Road Transport Enterprises after “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT”. Modern Business. 2012;(8):194–195.
13. Zong S. H., Zhou S. D. Estimated Tax Burden Changes in the Real Estate Industry after “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT”. Finance and Accounting Monthly. 2013;(13):105–106.
14. Yu X. B., Ke X. The Impact of “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT” on Transportation Enterprises. Friends of Accounting. 2014;(22):119–121.
15. Li J. M. Study on the Impact of the “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT” on the Corporate Taxation and the Countermeasures. Scientific and technological innovation. 2016;(2):294–295.
16. Fu L.M. “Replacing the Business Tax with VAT” and Corporate Tax Burden – Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies. Zhejiang University; 2015.
17. Fan Y. An Empirical Study on the Impact of VAT Deduction System on Industry on Sector’s Tax Burden. Finance & Trade Economics. 2012;1:34–41.
18. Fullerton D. Which Effective Tax Rate? National Tax Journal. 1984;37(1):23–41.
19. Yang J. Z. Institutional Innovation: The Actual Tax Burden and Nominal Tax Burden of Tourism Enterprises. China Economist. 2003;(8):114–115.
20. Wang D. Sh., Dong L. H., Li X. Sh. Methods and Implications for Estimating Tax Loss in the UK. Foreign Taxation. 2009;8:46–50.
21. Ma N.Y., Application of Sweden’s Tax Loss Estimation and Results. Foreign Taxation. 2012;5:46–49.
22. Matti Viren. Does the Value-Added Tax Shift to Consumption Prices? AUCO Czech Economic Review. 2009;3:123–142.
23. Smart M., Bird R. M. The Impact on Investment of Replacing a Retail Sales Tax with a Value-Added Tax: Evidence from Canadian Experience. Working Papers. 2008;62(4):591–609.
24. Zhou L. A., Liu C., Li X. The Mystery of Taxation Efforts, Taxation Agencies and Tax Growth. China Economic Quarterly. 2012;11(1):1–18.
25. Nie H. F., Liu Y. The Evolution of the Indirect Tax Burden of Urban Residents. China Economic Quarterly. 2010;9(4):1385–1402.
26. Yin Y. P., Yan S. L. The Fate of China’s Indirect Tax and the Effect of Income Redistribution. Taxation Research. 2017;(4):20–26.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/jtr.2019.5.1.058

Copyright (c) 2019 Yong Fan, Haonan Li, Qinyao Zhu

eLibrary logoeLibrary logo  DOAJ logo ERIH PLUS logo 

© Journal of Tax Reform : ISSN 2414-9497 (online), ISSN 2412-8872 (print)