The Impact of 2009 VAT Reform on Enterprise Investment and Employment – Empirical Analysis Based on Chinese Tax Survey Data

Wang Dehua, Wu Han

Abstract


The article analyzes the impact of the 2009 VAT reform in China on investment and employment. This reform was a key step in improving the VAT tax system in the long term, and one of the key measures to structurally reduce taxes in response to the global financial crisis in the short term. The data for this analysis were provided by the “National Tax Survey” jointly conducted by the Chinese Ministry of Finance and State Administration of Taxation. We measured the impact of the VAT reform using the difference-in-differences method: we compared the difference between the experimental group and the control group before and after the reform. There were two kinds of organizations in our control group. The first kind consisted of enterprises that did not pay the VAT and small-scale VAT-paying enterprises that did not subtract the input taxes for fixed assets investment. The second kind comprised organizations that had not been included in pilot experiments before 2009 and foreign-invested corporations that were allowed to deduct the input tax for fixed asset investment before and after 2009. The experimental group consisted of ordinary VAT-paying enterprises that had not been included in the pilot study before 2009 and were affected by the 2009 reform. Our estimations lead us to the conclusion that the VAT tax reform of 2009 significantly enhanced the companies’ physical investment in machinery and equipment, but had no impact on employment. When comparing physical investment and employment in 2007 with 2008 and 2009, we detected a downward trend, which may reflect the impact of the global financial crisis on Chinese business. The total corporate profits and profit margins have little impact on business investment and employment, while the asset size and the tax burden show a significant positive impact. Thus, the reform significantly increased business investment in fixed assets, but had no obvious effect on employment.

For citation

Wang Dehua, Wu Han. The Impact of 2009 VAT Reform on Enterprise Investment and Employment – Empirical Analysis Based on Chinese Tax Survey Data. Journal of Tax Reform. 2019;5(2):166–176. DOI: 10.15826/jtr.2019.5.2.066

Article info

Received May 17, 2019; accepted August 11, 2019


Keywords


value-added tax reform, investment in fixed assets, employment, difference-in-differences method

References


Bird R., Gendron P. P. The VAT in developing and transitional countries. Cambridge University Press; 2007.
2. Fan Yong, Han Wenjie. China’s Value-Added Tax since 1979. Economics Think Tank. 2018;3(06):66–80,144–145. (In Chinese)
3. Gao Peiyong. An Analysis and Prediction on China’s Value-added Tax Reform. Taxation Research. 2009;(08):36–39. (In Chinese)
4. Wang Dehua. Can Indirect Tax Investment Deduction Improve Enterprise Investment Structure? The Journal of Quantitative & Technical Economics. 2016;33(11):41–58. (In Chinese)
5. Wang Dehua, Yang Zhigang. The VAT Reform for Broadening the Tax Base: the difficulty and suggestion of covering service industry. Taxation Research. 2009;(12):36–38.
6. Wang Dehua. On the Future Positioning of VAT in China’s Tax System. Journal of Nnanjing University. 2012;49(05):13–20,158. (In Chinese)
7. Jorgenson D. W., Hall R. E. Tax Policy and Investment Behavior. American Economic Review. 1967;57(3):391–414. Available at: http://sumer.deu.edu.tr/userweb/yesim.kustepeli/dosyalar/halljorgenson1967.pdf
8. Caballero R. J., Engel E. M., Haltiwanger J. C., Woodford M., Hall R. E. Plant-level adjustment and aggregate investment dynamics. Brookings papers on economic activity. 1995;(2):1–54. DOI: 10.2307/2534611
9. Hassett K. A., Hubbard R. G. Chapter 20 – Tax Policy and Business Investment. Handbook of Public Economics. 2002;3:1293–1343. DOI: 10.1016/S1573-4420(02)80024-6
10. Cummins J. G., Hassett K. A., Hubbard R. G. Tax Reforms and Investment: A Cross-Country Comparison. Journal of Public Economics. 1996;62(1-2):237−273. DOI: 10.3386/w5232
11. Cummins J. G., Hassett K. A., Hubbard R. G. A Reconsideration of Investment Behavior Using Tax Reforms as Natural Experiment. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. 1994;2:1–74.
12. House C. L., Shapiro M. D. Temporary Investment Tax Incentives: Theory with Evidence from Bonus Depreciation. American Economic Review. 2008;98(3):737–768. DOI: 10.3386/w12514
13. Cohen D. S., Hansen D. P., Hassett K. A. The effects of temporary partial expensing on investment incentives in the United States. National Tax Journal. 2002;55(3):457–466. Available at: https://www.ntanet.org/NTJ/55/3/ntj-v55n03p457-66-effects-temporary-partial-expensing.pdf
14. Auerbach A. J., Hassett K. Taxes and Business Investment: Lessons from the Past Decade. In Viard A. (ed.) Tax Policy Lessons from the 2000s. 2008, pp. 248–270.
15. Yagan D. Capital Tax Reform and the Real Economy: The Effects of the 2003 Dividend Tax Cut. American Economic Review. 2015;105(12):3531–3563. DOI: 10.3386/w21003
16. Chen Ye, Gene Hsin Chang, Kou Enhui, Liu Ming. VAT Tax Reform and Its Negative Impact on Employment in China: A CGE Analysis, Economic Research Journal. 2010;(09):29–42. (In Chinese)
17. Li Jiaming, Li Suya. The Empirical Analysis of the Value-added Tax Transformation on Fixed Assets Investment of Corporations. Collected Essays on Finance and Economics. 2007;(01):26–31. (In Chinese)
18. Nie Huihua, Mingyue Fang, Tao Li. China’s Value-Added Tax Reform, Firm Behaviour and Performance. Frontiers of Economics in China. 2010;5(3):445–463. DOI: 10.1007/s11459-010-0107-z
19. Nie Haifeng, Yi Liu. Evaluation of the impact of Value-Added Tax Reform on central region. In: Accounting and Capital Operations Research Center of Lingnan School, Zhongshan university, Working Paper. 2010. (In Chinese)
20. Cai Jing, Harrison A. E. The Value-Added Tax Reform Puzzle. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 5788, 2011. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1923546
21. Shi Wenpo, Jia Kang. The VAT Reform for Broadening the Tax Base and Adjustment of Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations in China. Finance & Trade Economics. 2010;(11):46–51,145. (In Chinese)
22. Gao Peiyong. On Replacing Business Tax with VAT: Purpose, Function and Practice. Taxation Research. 2013;(07):3–10. (In Chinese)
23. Li Qing, Fang Jianchao. The Impact of turning Business Thx into VAT in All Industries on Fiscal Revenue of Provincial Governments in China: Estimation Based on Input-Output Tables. Finance & Trade Economics. 2013;(06):33–42. (In Chinese)
24. Shi Zhonghe, Lou Feng. Research on the Social and Economic Dynamic Effects of VAT Expansion. The Journal of Quantitative & Technical Economics. 2015;32(11):105–118. (In Chinese)
25. Li Yongyou, Yan Cen. Will Replacing BT with VAT for the Service Industry Lead the Manufacturing Industry to Upgrade? Economic Research Journal. 2018;53(04):18–31. (In Chinese)
26. Chen Zhao, Wang Yang. Whether replacing Business Tax with VAT Deepen the Division of Labor: Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies. Management World. 2016;(03):36–45,59. (In Chinese)
27. Tian Zhiwei, Hu Yijian. Dynamic Analysis of the Effects of Industry Tax Burden on the Transformation from Business Tax to VAT: Based on CGE Model. Collected Essays on Finance and Economics. 2013;(04):29–34. (In Chinese)
28. Tong Jinzhi, Su Guocan, Wei Zhihua. Replacing Business Tax with VAT, Bargaining Power and Tax Burden: Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies. Finance & Trade Economics. 2015;(11):14–26. (In Chinese)




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15826/jtr.2019.5.2.066

Copyright (c) 2019 Wang Dehua, Wu Han

eLibrary logoeLibrary logo  DOAJ logo ERIH PLUS logo 

© Journal of Tax Reform : ISSN 2414-9497 (online), ISSN 2412-8872 (print)