A sharp turn toward the market: economic reform in Russia (1992–1998) and its consequences

Alexander I. Tatarkin, Vladimir L. Bersenyov

Abstract


By analyzing and systematizing the literature accumulated over the past twenty years on the history of reforms, we can put in order the existing views on the processes that took place during these transformations and de ne a new vector in understanding the socio-economic development of Russia in the last decade of the 20th century and the rst decades of the 21st century. The rst step in this direction is the analysis of publications that re ect the preparation, progress and results of the contemporary economic reforms in the 1990s. The historiographic review includes the monographs written both by the advocates of the shock therapy, and their opponents and critics, rst of all, Members of the Russian Academy of Sciences. The study of this literature allows to reveal the spectrum of opinions on whether the shock therapy was the preferred version of transformations, on assessing the results of reforms by the end of the 1990s and the opportunities for alternative ways to make the transition from a planned to a market economy. In particular, the advocates of the «shock therapy» refer to the threat of famine and civil war to justify decisions that led to decline in output, hyperin ation and other negative trends. Their critics point out that the lack of public support caused the market reforms to fail. By acknowledging the obvious, i. e. a signi cant deterioration of economic indicators, the advocates see their success in establishing the system of market institutions, and, on this basis, insist there was no alternative to implemented version of reforms. In turn, their opponents believe that the alternatives to the «shock therapy» existed, and their distinctive feature would have been the gradual cultivation and not the forced administrative introduction of market economy institutions.

Keywords


historiography; contemporary economic reform; shock therapy; price liberalization; privatization; economic recession

Full Text:

PDF

References


Lvov D. S. (1999). Put v XXI vek (strategicheskiye problemy i perspektivy rossiyskoy ekonomiki) [Path to 21st century: strategic challenges and prospects of the Russian economy]. Moscow: Ekonomika Publ., 793.

Fedorenko, N. P. (2001). Rossiya: uroki proshlogo i liki budushchego [Russia: lessons of the past and faces of the future]. Moscow: Ekonomika Publ., 489.

Kolov, Yu. N. Rossiyskiye reformy glazami ekonomistov Zapada [Russian reforms through the eyes of Western economists]. Retrieved from: http://www.r-reforms.ru/indexpubkolov.htm (Date of access: 15.02.2016).

Lukin, A. V. Demokratizatsiya ili klanizatsiya? Evolyutsiya vzglyadov zapadnykh issledovateley na peremeny v Rossii [Democratization or clans? Evolution of views held by western researchers on the changes in Russia]. Retrieved from: http://www.r-reforms.ru/review.htm (Date of access: 15.02.2016).

Kherrera, Yo. Osmysleniye ekonomicheskoy reformy. Noveyshiye zapadnyye raboty o rossiyskoy ekonomike [Understanding the economic reforms: recent Western papers on Russian economy]. Retrieved from: http://www.r-reforms.ru/herrera.htm (Date of access: 15.02.2016).

Ekonomicheskiye reformy v Rossii: itogi pervykh let (1991–1996) [Economic reforms in Russia: results of the first years (1991–1996)]. (1997). Moscow: Nauka Publ., 271.

Mktrchyan, M. Ts., Ovakimyan, V. O., Sarkisyan, R. A. & Srektor, A. N. (1998). Sostoyaniye i protivorechiya ekonomicheskoy reform [State and contradictions of economic reforms]. Moscow: Ekonomika Publ., 206.

Gaidar, E. T. (2005). Dolgoye vremya. Rossiya v mire: ocherki ekonomicheskoy istorii [A long view: Russia in the world — essays on economic history]. Moscow: Delo Publ., 655.

Gaidar, E. T. (2006). Gibel imperii. Uroki dlya sovremennoy Rossii [Collapse of an empire: lessons for modern Russia]. Moscow: Rosspen Publ., 439.

Gaidar, E. & Chubais, A. (2011). Razvilki noveysheiy istorii Rossii [Crossroads of modern Russian history]. Moscow: OGI Publ., 168.

Gaidar, E. T. (2010). Smuty i instituty. Gosudarstvo i evolyutsiya [Troubles and institutions. State and evolution]. St. Petersburg: Norma Publ., 280.

Gaidar, E. T. (1996). Dni porazheniy i pobed [Days of defeat and victory]. Moscow: Vagrius Publ., 366.

Gaidar, E. T. (Ed.). (1998). Ekonomika perekhodnogo perioda. Ocherki ekonomicheskoy politiki postkommunisticheskoy Rossii. 1991–1997 [The economics of Russian transition: essays on the economic policy of post-communist Russia. 1991–1997]. Moscow: IEPP Publ., 1114.

Gaidar, E. T. (Ed.). (2003). Ekonomika perekhodnogo perioda. Ocherki ekonomicheskoy politiki postkommunisticheskoy Rossii. 1998–2002 [The economics of Russian transition: essays on the economic policy of post-communist Russia. 1998–2002]. Moscow: Delo Publ., 832.

Gaidar, E. T. (Ed.). Ekonomika perekhodnogo perioda. Ocherki ekonomicheskoy politiki postkommunisticheskoy Rossii. 2003–2007 [The economics of Russian transition: essays on the economic policy of post-communist Russia. 2003– 2007]. Moscow: Delo Publ., 1328.

Friedman, M. (1998). Optimalnoye kolichestvo deneg [Optimum quantity of money]. Esli by dengi zagovorili… [If the money could speak…]. Moscow: Delo Publ., 43–105.

Friedman, M. (1982). Capitalism and Freedom. New York: Chalidze Publications, 202.

Friedman, M. & Friedman, R. (1980). Free of Choose. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 338.

Diskussiya ob aziatskom sposobe proizvodstva [A discussion on Asiatic mode of production]. Moscow-Leningrad: Sotsekgiz Publ., 183.

Nikiforov, V. N. (1968). Logika diskussii i logika v diskussii (o ranneklassovykh obschestvakh) [The logic of discussion and logic in discussion. On the early class societies]. Voprosy istorii [Questions of history], 2, 113–126.

Wittfogel, K. A. (1957). Oriental despotism: a comparative study of total power. New Haven, London: Yale University Press, 556.

Galleyev, K. (2011). Teoriya gidravlicheskogo gosudarstva K. Wittfogelya i eyo sovremennaya kritika [Wittfogel’s theory of hydraulic state and its modern criticism]. Sotsiologicheskoye obozreniye [Russian sociological review], 10(3), 155–179.

Brelovich, A. Pro domo sua (Dolgoye vremya. Rossiya v mire: ocherki ekonomicheskoi istorii) [A long view: Russia in the world — essays on economic history]. Retrieved from: http://www.strana-oz.ru/2005/6/pro-domo-sua-e-t-gaydar-dolgoe-vremya-rossiya-v-mire-ocherkiekonomicheskoy-istorii (Date of access: 11.10.2015).

Ekonomicheskaya politika Pravitelstva Rossii: Dokumenty. Kommentariy [The economic policy of the Russian government. Documents. Comments]. (1992). Moscow: Respublika Publ., 79.

Programma uglubleniya ekonomicheskikh reform v Rossii [The program for deepening the economic reforms in Russia]. Moscow: Respublika Publ., 63.

Illarionov, A. (1993). 400 dney realnoy ekonomicheskoy reformy [400 days of real economic reform]. Voprosy ekonomiki [Questions of economics], 4, 19–26.

Sotsialno-ekonomicheskaya situatsiya v Rossii: itogi, problemy, puti stabilizatsii (analiticheskiy doklad) [Socio-economic situation in Russia: results, problems, ways for stabilization. Analytic report]. Voprosy ekonomiki [Questions of economics], (1994) 2, 126–160.

Aganbegyan, A. G. (2004). Sotsialno-ekonomicheskoye razvitiye Rossii [Socio-economic development of Russia]. Moscow: Delo Publ., 272.

Neekonomicheskiye grani ekonomiki: nepoznannoye vzaimovliyaniye. Nauchnyye i publitsisticheskiye zametki obschestvovedov [Noneconomic facets of the economy: unknown mutual influence. Scientific and journalistic notes of social scientists]. (2010) Moscow: Institut ekonomicheskikh strategiy Publ., 800.

Reddaway, P. & Glinski, D. (2001). The Tragedy of Russia’s Reforms. Market Bolshevism Against Democracy. Washington, D.C.: United States Institute of Peace Press, 745.

Stiglitz, J. (1999). Kuda vedut reformy? (K desyatiletiyu nachala perekhodnykh protsessov) [Where are the reforms leading? Ten years since starting the transition processes]. Voprosy ekonomiki [Questions of economics], 7, 4–30.

Chubais, A. B. (Ed.). (1999). Privatizatsiya po-rossiyski [Privatization in the Russian way]. Moscow: Vagrius Publ., 366.

Yasin, E. G. (2003). Rossiyskaya ekonomika. Istoki i panorama rynochnykh reform: Kurs kektsiy [The Russian economy: origins and panorama of market reforms. Lecture course]. Moscow: HES Publ., 437.

Abalkin, L. I. (1993). Na pereputye. (Razmyshleniya o sudbakh Rossii) [At the crossroads. (Reflections on the fate of Russia)]. Moscow: Institute of Economics RAS Publ., 245.

Abalkin, L. I. (2002). Logika ekonomicheskogo rosta [The logic of economic growth]. Moscow: Institute of Economics RAS Publ., 228.

Abalkin, L. I. (2002). Rossiya: poisk samoopredeleniya. Ocherki [Russia: a search for self-determination. Essays]. Moscow: Nauka Publ., 424.

Petrakov, N. Ya. (1998). Russkaya ruletka. Ekonomicheskiy eksperiment tsenoyu 150 millionov zhizney [Russian roulette: an economic experiment at the cost of 150 million lives]. Moscow: Ekonomika Publ., 286.

Petrakov, N. Ya. (2000). Ekonomicheskaya “Santa-Barbara”. Dnevnik ekonomista-rynochnika [Economic "santa barbara": a diary of market economist]. Moscow: Ekomomika Publ., 231.

Glazyev, S. Yu., Kara-Murza, S. G. & Batchikov, S. A. (2003). Belaya kniga. Ekonomicheskiye reformy v Rossii 1991–2001 gg. [White paper: economic reforms in Russia 1991–2001]. Moscow: Eksmo Publ., 367.

Glazyev, S. Yu. (2011). Uroki ocherednoy rossiyskoy revolutsii: krakh liberalnoy utopii i shans na “ekonomicheskoye chudo” [Lessons of yet another russian revolution: the collapse of the liberal utopia and the chance for “economic miracle”]. Moscow: Ekonomicheskaya gazeta Publ., 576.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.15826/recon.2016.2.2.015

Copyright (c) 2018 Alexander I. Tatarkin, Vladimir L. Bersenyov

© R-Economy, ISSN 2412-0731